Communion and Enclosure: A History of All of Us

Yakov Krotov

The Day After Freedom: Christianity in Post-Modern world

It happened so that I came to America not as Columbus, through Haiti, but as the Mayflower, through England.I was shocked with my first encounter with the West in London: the air of freedom, inner dignity, sincere politeness, and privacy. In a week I got used to the blessed air of democracy.

But I was still shocked by U.S. All my life I got used to the idea of differences of America and Russia, and I was not ready to see the similarities. The semblance can partly be easily explained: beginning from Khrushchev's visit to states and his famous decision "to run down and to outrun America" the United States became an example to Russian leaders. As Peter the Great Westernized Russia, a la mode Germany, so Communists did the same a la mode America.

The difference between America and Russia came out to be not the rude and basic difference between black and white. It was the second-rate distinction between clean glass and dirty glass. I have suddenly seen what Russia can be, and what, I pray, she will be some time in the future.

I understood that the Russian dream is as similar to American dream as the Russian dream is unsimilar to the English dream, whatever these dreams are. I was really taken back to the USSR, to the USSR all Russians dreamed of, and tried to build, and try to build now with other means. I have seen the USSR without communists, evil, and imperialistic. It was just like a fairy tail became a reality.

The problem is that fairy tales cannot become reality. The fairy tale simply finishes, and life begins. The prince and princess become husband and wife, and they live happily evere after. This "evere after" is described not by fairy tales but by "Macbeth" and "Hamlet": the former prince became Father's Ghost. Reality of "evere after" is a reality of pshycoanalysts, home counsellors, mortgages, children, the teeth and hairs leaving us.

United States shocked me because everybody seems to preserve their children, teeth and hairs. So it is possible to gain a victory, a princess, trip to Hawaii and keep smiling! In the medieval East artisans believed that when the work was finished, there is nothing left to do. Then a man must die. So they always left some nearly invisible detail unfinished. But, alas! The modern America proves to Russian that he can finish his work, gain the victory and happiness, and still remain alive and begin a new one.

For a Christian that means making a shift in those parts of Christianity which he thought to be eternal and immovable. Russian preachers most often repeat the words of Solszhenistyn: "The people have forgot God." That is why we became poor, egotistical, dirty, "Russian" in the worst possible sense of the word. Restore Christianity, and you restore Russia.

I was shocked as a man can be shocked in Spiellberg's films, when he seems himself in the far future as a retired old man. The goal is reached, the dream is realized, and difficulties are overcome with God's help, thank God. And what's after?

I was shocked to see that Americans don't have the answer. The only answer which is ready is the answer of Fukuyama: history came to an end and is replaced by Liberal Democracy, which comes out to be another name for Eternity. We are in Heaven, or, to be modest, in purgatory.

What can be immediately seen is that nobody wants to enjoy eternity, to be in Heaven. People try to return to a life of struggle. It is very easy: you only need to remind yourself that not everybody is still in Paradise, that there are starving people in United States itself, not to mention the outer world. So Americans become sickened with the idea of helping others. It is as if saints in Heaven have decided to make a strike, a theological strike, and refuse to enjoy eternal life until all sinners will be saved from the eternal fire. But what must be ever after all sinners come to Heaven?

You can be help-oriented for some time, may be for several ages. God expelled us from Paradise with the words: "Cursed is the ground for thy sake; In sorrow shalt thou eat of it ... In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread." (Gen 3:17, 19). Usually this is thought to be a curse, but it is a blessing, as well as the life penalty is a blessing compared with the immediate electric chair. All economic and social injustices are a deviation from this blessing. There are too many people who eat bread without any sweat of the brow; there are even people who eat bread although the sweat is on the brow of others, and these others are starving. Those, who are bothered mainly by this problem, become socialists. But many more people work with the sweat of their brows and still don't have bread. Their creativity is spoiled or badly oriented. Those who bother about this problem turn to capitalism. The Church has something to say to both systems and both deviations. But here, in the States, there is a blessed silent majority, eating its own bread in the sweat of its own brows, and so obedient to God's commandment. The Church is why this is so. But whether the Church is needed only a base for economical prosperity and psychological stability? Persecutions help us to be Christians, but persecutions and disasters are not the sense of Christianity. How to live without persecutions, after recovery, in wealth and health?

I experience America's nicest side. I live in fine hotels, communicate with spiritually and physically healthy people. Certainly, I suspect that the States are not really Heaven. That doesn't matter! Man is such a being that what is meaningful to him need not be reality, but possibility. So, even when I shall return in Russia, I will be obliged internally to preach the Gospel in a different way. I must now remember that Church is not only a shelter, a spiritual hospital. Not only disabled, but abled also have their place in the Church. Moreover, Church is present in order to help everybody become healthy and abled. the Church is a medicine but the Church is something more than a medicine. So even those who are ill must look at the Church not as they look at the phisician. I am sure, this is possible. I am sure that the Church and Christ are needed even in Heaven, they are not just a ticket and guide to happiness. Moreover, in the Paradise, among healthy and happy people, Church is more needed and Christ recover His ultimate sense..

To be the Church among wealthy and healthy people is more difficult. I am speaking not about the sick wealthy, who can be very greedy and as such a nice and endless object of preachers' efforts. I am speaking about healthy wealthy, and healthiness is always compassionate without the encourangment of sermons, without external spiritual violence. But it is among the healthy wealthy that the Gospel opens some of its most precious pearls. One has a new understanding of sin. Anther is a new understanding of love.

Healthy wealthy has a unique opportunity to understand that sin is not only a crime against this or that law, but that sin is a violation of Grace, against Love. When we come close to perfection, we see that perfection is greater and further than we thought. Love comes out to be not only help, the filling in of the gaps.

Christ is not only a healer, not only a Savior. The Church is not only a hospital or hotel. Salvation is not only healing, but also a communion of healed. Heaven is not the triumph of consumption, whether material or spiritual. Heaven opens the ultimate sense and justice of productivity and creativity. One produces not for his own or his neighbors' consumption, but produces in order to see that "it is very good" and rejoice in Gods' in everlasting creation.

1994